Articles tagged with: British

Is The King’s Speech Historically Accurate?

The-Kings-Speech

I will start by saying that The King’s Speech is an exceptional movie. I took the opportunity to see this movie in theaters when it first came out, in 2010. There is a reason that this movie, starring Colin Firth and Geoffrey Rush, received four Oscar awards (and was nominated for another eight) [1]; unfortunately, that reason was not because of the historical accuracy of the film.

It is no secret that many of the details in this movie have been skewed and exaggerated. Hugo Vickers, a royal adviser to film, stated that he understands that the adjustments were necessary to make an entertaining movie. He also believed that correct details are important, however, for this particular movie the “essence of the story” is what was most important.

“My view is that a film is a film, and you have to move the drama on…It’s the essence of the story that counts, and the essence of the story here is very sound indeed.” [2]

-Hugo Vickers (1/9/2011)

Lionel-Logue

Lionel Logue, King George VI’s speech therapist.

So while the movie wasn’t completely honest, it got out its message. As I look into the historical accuracy–or lack of historical accuracy–in this film, I run across article after article crying foul. Slate’s review of the film is entitled Churchill Didn’t Say That - The King’s Speech is riddled with gross falsifications of history. The Washington Post reviews the movie as “Brilliant filmmaking, less-than-brilliant history.” My favorite article title is from New Republic; the headline of their article was simple–Royal Mess. However, the article with the hardest-hitting, historical-correcting blows comes from The Daily Beast. Their article, The King Who Couldn’t Speakis a well-written piece by British historian Dr. Andrew Roberts. Dr. Roberts claims that the film “gets the story all wrong and is simply bad history.”

Dr.Andrew Roberts noted that,

“…viewers should know of the very many glaring and egregious inaccuracies and tired old myths that this otherwise charming film unquestioningly regurgitates.” [3]

-Dr. Andrew Roberts (11/20/2010)

Some of the more egregious historical inaccuracies from his lists are:

  1. The time period of the movie. The speech therapist, Lionel Logue, started working with King George VI in 1926, not in 1930′s.
  2. The severity of his stutter. King George’s stutter was relatively mild compared to the movie’s portrayal.
  3. The politics. An example of this would be Winston Churchill. Winston Churchill is shown as supporting the Abdication of George VI’s elder brother King Edward VIII, whereas he violently opposed it.

While the list of smaller inaccuracies are too many to list, the movie overall is excellent! As far as my moviegoing experience, the film was so impressive that I can overlook the “egregious inaccuracies and tired old myths.” I highly recommend that you take the opportunity to watch this film. You can instantly stream it on Netflix. If you don’t have Netflix, they are currently running a promo so that you can test it out for one month, for free! Click on the image below to get your free month, then check out The King’s Speech!

247086_TV episodes & movies instantly streaming from Netflix. Start your FREE trial!

If you want a more detailed account of historical discrepancies, I suggest checking out the full article that I mentioned above from The Daily Beast. 

 

[1] IMDb: Awards for The King’s Speech

[2] The Guardian: How historically accurate is The King’s Speech?

[3] The Daily Beast: The King Who Couldn’t Speak

The Grand Staircase of the Titanic

The Titanic was constructed over a period of three years in Belfast by Harland & Wolf and made its ill-fated maiden voyage in April 1912. White Star Lines built the ship intending it to be the last word in size, safety, modern technology and luxury. The ship was indeed the largest passenger vessel to have been built but sadly did not live up to the theory that it was unsinkable as the ship famously went down after a collision with an iceberg with the tragic loss of 1502 passengers and crew. The vessel was certainly, however, the most refined and luxurious ship to have graced the oceans and probably the most enduring symbol of this opulence is the Grand Staircase.

Construction

There were actually two grand staircases constructed on the ship but it is the forward staircase immortalised in James Cameron’s film Titanic which has become the iconic symbol of the vessel. The staircase was for the use of the first class passengers and descended 5 decks from the first class entrance to the lower accommodation decks, lounges and dining room. It was constructed of polished oak and featured gilded balustrades and beautiful wrought iron railings. The 60ft high, 16ft wide staircase featured a mix of architectural influences with the oak panelling being of English William and Mary style and the ironwork reminiscent of the French Louis XIV period. There was a clock at the top of the staircase representing “Honour and glory crowning time” and the whole construction was lit by a huge glass dome overhead which allowed natural light to flood in. At the foot of the Grand Staircase there was a statue of a cherub which was later rescued from the wreck and now resides in a private collection.

Watery Grave

Sadly the opulent Titanic resided on the ocean floor for 73 years before its discovery in 1985. The ship was found to have split in half with the stern having almost completely disintegrated. The forward portion of the vessel was surprisingly intact but the Giant Staircase had completely disappeared. No one will ever know its fate as it could have become detached from the structure and floated away to be destroyed or it could have simply been eaten away. All that remains is a large hole which is now used to access the lower decks by exploratory submarine vehicles.

Visiting the Staircase

If you wish to see the Grand Staircase today then the only option is to visit one of two impressive replicas which have been built. The first can be found in the “Titanic The Artefact” exhibition in the Luxor Hotel, Las Vegas. The exhibition tells the story of the ship using over 300 genuine Titanic artefacts recovered from the wreck and has the reconstructed staircase as its stunning centrepiece. It has received over 20 million visitors to date and will be open until 2018. You can also see the Grand Staircase at the Titanic Belfast building in the re-developed Titanic Quarter of the city. The building houses a museum and elegant conference facilities with the staircase being constructed in the Astor Suite, a 750 seat banqueting hall. The siting of the staircase has caused controversy as it is not part of the museum tour and can thus only be seen whilst attending an event in the conference centre.

Icon

Sadly the Grand Staircase is gone forever and lives on only in photographs from the time and the ghostly images of the wreck which show a gaping hole where the staircase once stood. Even the replicas cannot recreate the opulence of the original setting and the spirit of the Titanic.

Citations:
Featured images:

This article was written by Stacey in cooperation with National Furniture UK, who bring the nation high quality wooden furniture at truly excellent prices.

A Great History Gift Idea

For those of you looking to get the perfect gift for your history loving husband, or Civil War reenacting cousins, here is a great history gift idea. I received a package last week in the mail, much faster than I had anticipated. Well, not that fast. I mean, it did have to travel across the pond. This considered, it arrived tout de suite. I know, I know…by now you cannot wait to hear what it is. It was paper. Actually, paper wrapped in protective paper, in a box inside of another box. I open the first box, and what did I see…

A Day to Remember

What’s in the ‘A Day to Remember’ box??

That’s right, a pretty box that said, “A Day To Remember.” Any guesses? I will give you a hint…

How cool would it be to own a piece of history; in fact, not only history, but a secondary source dating back over 100 years?

Weird Weapons of WW II

There are certainly several weird weapons of WW II, but I think the following video shows some of my favorites. I ran across a video the other day entitled ‘British Secret Wartime Follies.’ The caption underneath the video described the video as: “British science made some dreadful bloopers when they were give free reign to design during WWII.”

There were definitely some interesting inventions…

“His Heart Belongs in Africa” Part Two

If you haven’t already, check out part one: His Heart Belongs in Africa.

By request of the New York Herald, Henry Morton Stanley went to find Dr. Livingstone. As Livingstone had been incommunicado for several years, this would prove to be a monumental feat.  Upon finding him in the town of Ujiji, on November 10, 1871, Stanley greeted him with the all too familiar phrase,

“Dr. Livingstone, I presume?”

And in response, Livingstone responded,

“Yes, and I feel thankful that I am here to welcome you.”

This famous quote became popular because of its tongue-in-cheek humor. Henry Morton Stanley did not want to be disrespectful to the world-renowned Dr. Livingstone, but it was almost ludicrous to ask if he was Dr. Livingstone. As Stanley and Livingstone were the only two white men for hundreds of miles, it was a fairly safe assumption that he was indeed that man he was seeking. After spending some time with Livingstone, exploring and searching for the source of the Nile, Stanley left Africa. Before leaving, however, he begged Livingstone to come back to Britain with him. Livingstone, with not all of his faculties intact, made another poor decision and stayed behind.

It would only be a matter of months before David Livingstone passed away from malaria and internal bleeding, caused by dysentery. Upon his death, Britain requested to have his body. After all the accomplishments Livingstone had completed, they wanted to give his body a proper burial. Unwilling at first, the village of Ilala gave the body to Britain, but not before taking out his heart. Attached to his body they sent back a note that said, “You can have his body, but his heart belongs in Africa!” His body rests at Westminster Abbey and his heart was buried under a Mvula tree near the spot of the current Livingstone Memorial.

Livingstone-Memoria-Heart-Africa

Livingstone Memorial, Where His Heart is Buried

Dr. Livingstone left behind a great legacy. He played a prominent role in the spread of Christianity in Africa, he made many geographical discoveries, and he was instrumental in ending slave trade in Africa. Before Livingstone’s time, the regions and details concerning most of Africa was unknown. The African map was a large, blank canvas. Because of his exploration, geographical features such as Victoria Falls, Lake Ngami, Lake Malawi, Lake Bangweulu, Lake Tanganyika, and Lake Mweru could now be placed on a map. Regarding slave trade, he was unable to see the fruits of his labor, but while he was alive he requested that the House of Commons help stop the slave traders. One month after his death, the British threatened a naval blockade which forced the Arab Sultan to close the African slave market.

Britain is lucky to have such a dedicated man in their history books. He set out with a mission and I believe he did more than his fair share in living up to his motto, ”Christianity, Commerce and Civilization.”